Save This Search

Apartments for Rent in Middle Island, NY

153 Rentals Available
Apartments for Rent in Middle Island, NY. 153 Rentals Available
  • a large living room with couches and a fireplace
    Today

    100 Stonegate Way, Middle Island, NY 11953
    1 BED Ask for Pricing
    2 BEDS $3,015+
    3 BEDS Ask for Pricing

  • More Rentals Near Middle Island, NY

  • a kitchen with black appliances and a black refrigerator
    Today

    One Homestead Drive, Coram, NY 11727
    STUDIO $1,670+
    1 BED $1,835+
    2 BEDS $2,255+
  • a white kitchen and dining room with a glass table
    Today

    100 Village Drive, Ridge, NY 11961
    1 BED $1,999+
    2 BEDS $2,559
  • a kitchen and dining room with a sink and a table and chairs
    Today

    1998 Route 112, Coram, NY 11727
    STUDIO $1,933+
    1 BED Ask for Pricing
    2 BEDS Ask for Pricing
  • a living room and kitchen with a white table and chairs
    Today

    1100 Lake Drive, Medford, NY 11763
    1 BED $2,853+
    2 BEDS $3,171+
    3 BEDS Ask for Pricing
  • Renting has its Rewards
    Start earning points to redeem on travel, experiences, gift cards, live events, and more!
    Earn points for:
    Internet and Entertainment
    Utilities
    Insurance
    Learn more
  • a living room with a couch and chairs and a rug
    Today

    303 Arrowhead Lane, Suite 100, South Setauket, NY 11720
    1 BED Ask for Pricing
    2 BEDS $3,995+
    3 BEDS $4,950+
  • a kitchen with blue cabinets and a stove and a sink
    Today

    39 Piedmont Dr, Port Jeff Station, NY 11776
    STUDIO $2,207+
    1 BED $2,612+
    2 BEDS Ask for Pricing
  • a living room with a couch and a television
    Today

    1B Country Club Drive, Manorville, NY 11949
    STUDIO $1,953+
    1 BED $2,066+
    2 BEDS Ask for Pricing
  • a living room with a gray couch and a white table
    Today

    9 Pond View Drive, East Patchogue, NY 11772
    1 BED $2,055+
    2 BEDS $2,935+
  • a living room with a couch and a table
    Today

    1 B Meadowoods Lane, Moriches, NY 11955
    1 BED $2,192+
    2 BEDS $3,169+
  • a living room and kitchen with a couch and a table
    Today

    20 Mirror Lane, Moriches, NY 11955
    2 BEDS $3,542+
  • Interactive banner rent
    What is your max rent budget?
  • a living room with white furniture and large windows
    Today

    87 Acorn Circle, Moriches, NY 11955
    2 BEDS $4,184+
  • a living room with a couch and a table and a tv
    Today

    99 Waverly Ave, Patchogue, NY 11772
    1 BED $2,226+
    2 BEDS $3,290+
  • a living room with a fireplace and leather furniture
    Today

    1 Clubhouse Way, East Moriches, NY 11940
    1 BED $2,600
    2 BEDS $3,200
  • a living room with a white couch and a table
    Today

    20 Spruce Drive, Holbrook, NY 11741
    1 BED $2,278+
    2 BEDS $3,333+
  • a kitchen with wooden cabinets and a white refrigerator
    Today

    835 Broadway Avenue, Holbrook, NY 11741
    1 BED $2,109
    2 BEDS $2,614
  • a kitchen and dining room with a sink and a microwave
    Today

    865 Broadway Ave, Holbrook, NY 11741
    STUDIO Ask for Pricing
    1 BED $2,304+
    2 BEDS $2,839+
  • Interactive banner bedroom
    How many bedrooms are you
    looking for?
  • a kitchen and dining room with a sink and a microwave
    Today

    147 Lake Shore Road, Lake Ronkonkoma, NY 11779
    STUDIO $2,008+
    1 BED $2,395+
    2 BEDS Ask for Pricing
  • 89 PINEWOOD DRIVE 4 Beds Apartment for Rent

    89 PINEWOOD DRIVE, SHIRLEY, NY 11967
    4 BEDS $2,795
  • a living room with a couch and a television
    Today

    500 Peconic St, Ronkonkoma, NY 11779
    STUDIO $2,059+
    1 BED $2,049+
    2 BEDS $3,100+
  • a kitchen with a stove and a refrigerator
    Today

    14 Easy Street, Sayville, NY 11782
    1 BED $2,131
  • a kitchen and dining room with a sink and a microwave
    Today

    168 Oakdale-Bohemia Road, Bohemia, NY 11716
    STUDIO Ask for Pricing
    1 BED $2,194+
    2 BEDS Ask for Pricing
  • a small kitchen with a sink and a dishwasher
    Today

    100 Patricia Court, Oakdale, NY 11769
    1 BED $1,749
  • an empty street in front of a building
    Today

    348-354 Wheeler Road, Hauppauge, NY 11788
    STUDIO Ask for Pricing
  • a kitchen with a stove and a sink and a window
    Today

    29 Buffalo Avenue, Islip, NY 11751
    1 BED $2,301
1-24-city
Nice work, you've checked out every rental here! Expand your search to find your happy place.

Save Search

Getting around in Middle Island, NY

6 /100
Car-Dependent
26 /100
Somewhat Bikeable
Walk Score®: 6, Bike Score®: 26

Frequently asked questions

When were prices and availability in Middle Island, NY last updated?

Prices and availability in Middle Island, NY were last updated on 20 Feb 2026.

What are the best apartments in Middle Island, NY?

The best apartment in Middle Island, NY is: Stonegate.

What is the average rent in Middle Island, NY?

The average rent in Middle Island, NY is $2,763.

What is the price range for a 1-bedroom apartment in Middle Island, NY?

The price range for a 1-bedroom apartment in Middle Island, NY is between $3,015 and $3,300.

What is the price range for a 2-bedroom apartment in Middle Island, NY?

The price range for a 2-bedroom apartment in Middle Island, NY is between $3,015 and $3,300.

What is the price range for a 3-bedroom apartment in Middle Island, NY?

The price range for a 3-bedroom apartment in Middle Island, NY is between $3,015 and $3,300.

What type of rental buildings are in Middle Island, NY?

In Middle Island, 33% of the residents are renting compared to 67% owning a home, according to data from the U.S. Census Bureau. Large-scale apartment buildings with more than 50 units represent 7% of Middle Island's rentals, 81% are small-scale complexes with under 50 units, and 12% are single-family rentals.

What do typical apartment communities look like in Middle Island, NY?

The average age of rental buildings in Middle Island is 32 years old, with 32% being newer apartment buildings completed since 2000. The average height of apartment buildings in the city is 2 stories, of which all are garden-style apartment communities, none are mid-sized buildings, and none are high-rises. These characteristics describe large-scale apartment communities of 50 apartments or more.

What apartment floorplans are common in Middle Island, NY?

Studio apartments in Middle Island are around 0% of rentals, while 1-bedroom floor plans represent 39% of the total stock. For those in search of larger rentals, 2-bedroom floorplans make up 56% of all rentals. More generous apartments with 3 bedrooms or more are also available in this city for those in search of more space.

Living in Middle Island, NY

Middle Island is a small city in Suffolk County, NY. It's a great place for families and young professionals, offering affordable costs of living, some of the best schools in the area and a robust economy with plenty of job opportunities. The city is also a great place to rent for outdoor enthusiasts, with many nature preserves, parks, historic sites and waterfronts surrounding it. Middle Island has an oceanic/humid, continental hybrid climate, which includes hot summers and cold winters with moderate humidity. Summer months reach average daily highs of around 84°F, while winter temperatures reach lows of around 22°F. However, renters should be wary of some extreme weather conditions, like heat waves in summer and heavy snowfall in winter.

Renting in Middle Island, NY

Most rental properties in Middle Island are apartments with one to three bedrooms along the main road, thereby placing renters near all lifestyle amenities. For those looking to rent in Middle Island's family-friendly neighborhoods, renters in the northwestern parts are close to parks, nature preserves and schools. Note that, when applying to rent in Middle Island, renters may need to provide an application fee and a security deposit no higher than one month's rent. Additionally, while it's not mandatory, some landlords may also require you to obtain renter's insurance before signing a lease. According to New York state law, landlords must give written notice if they intend to raise the rent by more than 5% or if they want to terminate the lease. Other rights and responsibilities of the parties, like the payment of utilities, should be regulated in the lease.

Things for renting

Shopping in Middle Island, NY

With its proximity to New York City, those renting in Middle Island have access to a wide range of shopping opportunities within the city and close to it. In particular, Strathmore Commons is the most popular shopping mall where renters can find big-box stores, national retailers, and grocery stores. For renters looking to shop locally, Middle Island has many independent, mom-and-pop establishments with everything from health and beauty supplies to clothing boutiques and hardware stores. Otherwise, chain stores in Middle Island where renters can find household items and groceries include Walmart; Dollar Tree; Stop & Shop; Lidl; and the local King Kullen Supermarket. Delis, ethnic stores, and farmers' markets are also available for renters looking for fresh produce and international food.

Transportation in Middle Island, NY

Middle Island renters have access to various transportation options, although driving is the most efficient way of getting around. Namely, State Route 25 is the main arterial road running through the city and connecting renters to areas east and west. Alternatively, Suffolk County Transit operates regular bus lines throughout the city and surrounding towns for renters commuting through mass transit. Plus, some neighborhoods have pedestrian and bike lanes that allow renters to get around by walking or cycling, while rideshare programs, like Uber and Lyft, provide on-demand rides throughout the area. Finally, renters who need to travel further can fly domestically through Long Island MacArthur Airport, while the closest international airport is John F. Kennedy International Airport, 57 miles away.

Look for apartments near me

Are you looking to land that one apartment near you that ticks all the boxes? Now you can browse through available RentCafe apartment listings in your area, rated and reviewed by verified residents. Comparing the size, price, amenities and location of apartments for rent near you is easier than ever. Do you feel like expanding the search beyond your neighborhood and ZIP code? Browse apartments for rent in your city and state to find the best fit, wherever you are in the U.S. Somewhere out there is the perfect apartment just waiting for you.

Whether you're looking for a studio, an apartment with one or more bedrooms, or maybe you're upgrading to a luxury apartment or need to acommodate a pet, RentCafe allows you to easily search for a rental near you based on your criteria, anywhere in the U.S. So, let's find your new home today!

RentCafe is your one-stop shop for finding a great new apartment in Middle Island, NY. Easily search through a wide selection of apartments for rent in Middle Island, NY, and view detailed information about available rentals including floor plans, pricing, photos, amenities, interactive maps, and thorough property descriptions. Property owners and managers are one click away, so feel free to contact them and find out all you need to know about the apartment you're interested in. Browse Middle Island, NY apartments with rents starting from $1,670 and submit your rental application today!

Finding a home nearby is easier than you think. Check out our Apartments Near Me page and take your pick!